Friday, May 30, 2008

I'm With the Band

I'm a Band Mom. I believe in Band. My kids both started on the recorders in fourth grade with their elementary school music programs and continued to fifth grade band. Schools in California can't be that bad if they have elementary school bands, right?

Claire plays the Clarinet. Get it? She used Carl's 30-year-old clarinet, which is very sweet. The instrument had cork bugs and cost a pretty penny to get fixed up, but Carl didn't care which is very unlike him.
Claire's clarinet career has been short and I'm afraid it is over. She only played for one year. She has had trouble achieving the proper air pressure required for the instrument due to fistula (holes) in the roof of her mouth. The fistula are a result of her repaired cleft palate.
I would feel bad about her curtailed band career if she didn't play the piano. I hope that she will take choir in middle school from the terrific music teacher there. Claire is okay with the end of her band career because now she doesn't have to be at school every morning at 7:30.
Max plays the Sax. Alto saxophone. He's been playing it for four years and I think this is also his last year of band. He is going to high school next year and he wants to pursue other electives. He is continuing piano also and has been practicing the guitar a lot. I feel regret that his band career is over but I am trying to allow my kid some autonomy. It's tough.
Max has been in a specialty band, Jazz Band, the last two years. The teacher required that he bring his instrument home to practice every day, but that requirement didn't work for my family. I figured he practiced at school for an hour and that was sufficient. Plus, I needed him to walk home and he couldn't do that while hauling a saxophone. It's all about me. Every day, Max would retrieve his instrument from the band room and walk across the street and stash it on my friend's front porch. He hid it inside her porch bench. Then, in the morning, I would drop him off at my friend's house where he would fetch his sax and walk to school. His teacher never knew the difference and I was saved many trips in my car. A win/win situation.
When I was in school, the band kids were a little bit geeky. Now that I'm an adult, I'd rather have band kids than cool kids any day. Yay for band.

18 comments:

Rochelleht said...

Here here! For the life of me, I can't understand why parents push their kids to be cool or popular.

diane said...

I had band kids,one trombone, one trumpet and percussion and one clarinet. My oldest even played at the Rose parade. His career ended when his LaCrosse friends called him a bando.

Cynthia said...

I prompted (ok, forced) my kids to continue band their first year of high school. One loved it and continued into college. Another has resentment issues toward me to this day. You just can't win as a parent.

Marie said...

I was a band nerd until my freshman year and I am so with you. I would much rather have nerds than cool kids. Too bad my kids don't agree.

Marie said...

O, I love that Claire plays the CLARinet and Max plays the SAX. Did you make them do that?

I also wish I had continued in my marching band career..even through college because when can you ever be in a marching band again?

Jenibelle said...

While your kid is winning accolades for being in a speciality band, mine is winning "Class Clown" for the 8th grade. I don't think I should be proud of that. And Scotty, he pounded those drums and glockenspeils with great enthusiasm!!!

PS. That Claire...she is adorable!

AZ Karen said...

Band mom to Band mom...I'm with you all the way. I'd rather my kids be in band (or orchestra) over some other activities...hands down!

Nortorious said...

I married a band nerd. He thought it was cool. I play along, but secretly I know he's a big dork.

Tristan said...

I was a "choir priss". I loved it! It was my favorite class in high school.

Lauren in GA said...

I agree...my oldest wants to try the Sax next year when he starts middle school. I would rather have a band kid than have a kid interested in the wrong crowd. Your kids aren't uncool, though. I can tell because I am so cool.

Tami said...

Yay for you, and letting your kids be who they want to be. I think it's great to have them try things, and after time if it's not for them, not making them still do it. I played the clarinet for 2 years in Junior High. In ninth grade I had no trouble dropping it like a lead balloon! My mom backed me up too!

Anonymous said...

My youngest spent eight years playing music(clarinet and sax).
He was in band and jazz band which led to youth symphony and state honor band. Music is very important to brain development. Music was for fun and relaxation...still is.
He is a regular teacher now, but encourages his students to participate in music programs.

Linsey said...

You need to convince Max to stay with the Sax, otherwise when he runs for President what will he do on the Tonight Show that makes him a cool man of the people?

Hollyween said...

I was in band and choir. I liked band the most until I got a crappy new teacher who I despised.

Have you thought about having Claire learn flute? I think it would be a lot easier for her than clarinet and it's pretty too. I'd give her lessons if she was here. Ya know, if I still had my flute and didn't sell it to buy a new fridge.

Sally said...

I am so with you about band kids over cool kids. Any day. Band kids and Choir and Orchestra (I play the violin)--I'd take that over cheerleading any day.

Claire's dress is as cute as I've ever seen.

Paige said...

I feel sad that their band career is over. And happy that I never had to attend one concert.

Lorena said...

I think I love you (and your blog.) You make me smile...go band geeks all the way!

Nancy said...

I would have loved to play an instrument, but considering the fact I had to pay for my own extracurricular activities, it was out of the question. I did choir for 1 year, and that (super ugly) dress alone was too expensive, an instrument wasn't in the books for me. Then I went to college and started the guitar... now it sits in my closet, unplayed. Oh well.